Swap-bot Time: December 22, 2024 1:03 am
www.swap-bot.com

Threes ratings for mling

Use the controls to the right to show only the ratings you are interested in.

cmcedwards rated for The Office (US) themed ATC Swap on Feb 1, 2010
3
rating
Comment: Updated 2/21 - Firstly, the swap was sent extremely late. So late in fact that the moderator had offered to angel the swap for me. The lateness is not the issue, as much as the fact that you did not let me know. Secondly, I appreciated that you focused on my favorite character. However, the ATC was poorly made. The pictures were very small and pixelated. When I took the ATC out of the envelope, the paperclips and rubber bands fell off. And because of your effort to stick that stuff on, the ATC was caked with glue. All of that definitely constitutes poorly made. Please do not be so inconsiderate as to think that I made my judgment based on whether I liked the card or not; I've received enough cards that have not been my "style" that I would never judge on that. ---- I received the ATC, however it was sent over a week late. You never contact me about it to let me know. Also, the ATC definitely could have had more effort put into it.
Response: I apologized in my letter for being late. I've sent and received many later than this one and have NEVER given or received a lower rating. I chose Ryan as the theme since your profile said you liked him. I have a photo of the ATC if anyone would like to see how much work went into it.. Also, it is bad form to give a low rating because you do not like someones interpretation of the idea.

Rating Overview

Overall Hearts Stars Hosted
4.9326 60 2 2
Completed Fives Threes Ones
70 87 1 1
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3 Uncategorized
1 12 31 26

Show only: